Classification and Thickening Mechanisms of Cosmetic Thickeners

Thickeners are a crucial ingredient in cosmetics. They are hydrophilic polymers that, when dissolved or dispersed in water, significantly increase the viscosity of liquids and help maintain the stability of the system.

Thickeners form the structural backbone and core foundation of various cosmetic formulations. They are essential for the product's appearance, rheological properties, stability, and skin feel, playing a vital role in the overall performance of the product.

Thickening Mechanisms in Cosmetics

Thickeners in cosmetic formulations increase the viscosity and stability of products through several key mechanisms, thereby enhancing their sensory properties and user experience. These mechanisms include:

1. Intermolecular Interactions

• Hydrogen Bonding: Hydroxyl groups in cellulose-based thickeners form hydrogen bonds with water molecules, enhancing intermolecular interactions and increasing the viscosity of the solution.

• Electrostatic Interactions: Some synthetic polymer thickeners dissociate into charged ions. The electrostatic interactions between these ions increase molecular aggregation, leading to an increase in the solution's viscosity.

2. Molecular Chain Entanglement

• Linear Polymer Chains: Linear polymers, such as polyvinyl alcohol and polyacrylamide, entangle their molecular chains, forming a network structure that increases internal friction and contributes to thickening.

• Branched Polymer Chains: Thickeners with branched structures interact at the branching points, creating physical cross-links that enhance the viscosity stability of the solution.

3. Steric Hindrance Effect

• Large Molecule Conformation: Polysaccharide thickeners, such as guar gum and xanthan gum, have complex molecular structures that occupy more space, limiting molecular movement and increasing solution viscosity.

• Colloidal Particles: Inorganic thickeners like magnesium aluminum silicate and bentonite form colloidal particles. The steric hindrance between these particles helps maintain dispersion stability, and under external force, the viscosity of the solution increases.

4. Crystallization

• Crystalline Network Formation: Metal soaps, such as aluminum stearate and magnesium stearate, form crystals. These crystalline particles interconnect to create a network, which increases the viscosity of the solution.

5. Adsorption

• Surface Adsorption on Solids: In pigment dispersion systems, thickeners adsorb onto the surface of pigment particles, forming an adsorptive layer. This increases the intermolecular forces between the particles, thereby increasing the viscosity of the solution.

• Interface Adsorption: Some surfactant-based thickeners adsorb at the oil-water interface, reducing interfacial tension, stabilizing emulsions, and simultaneously increasing the solution's viscosity.

Classification of Thickeners

1. By Water Solubility

• Water-Soluble Thickeners: These thickeners dissolve in water to increase viscosity. Common examples include:Hyaluronic acid, polyglutamic acid, xanthan gum, starch, guar gum, agar, scleroglucan, sodium alginate, arabic gum, carrageenan, gellan gum, carboxymethyl cellulose (CMC), hydroxyethyl cellulose, polyethylene glycol (PEG), polyvinyl alcohol (PVA), etc.

• Micro-powder Thickeners: These are typically solid powders that thicken by physical means such as particle interaction or network formation in suspension. Common examples include:Magnesium aluminum silicate, silica, bentonite, modified fumed silica, silane-treated bentonite, microcrystalline cellulose, etc.

2. By Source

• Natural Thickeners: Sourced from plants, animals, or microbial fermentation, these thickeners are often considered more eco-friendly and safe. They generally offer milder thickening effects and good compatibility with the human body. Common examples include:Starch, xanthan gum, gelatin, agar, etc.

• Synthetic Thickeners: These are chemically synthesized and tend to provide more pronounced thickening effects, with performance that can be more easily controlled. However, there may be concerns about their safety. Common examples include:Sodium polyacrylate, polyethylene glycol (PEG), polyacrylamide, etc.

3. By Application

• Water-Based Thickeners: These are typically used in water-based formulations to increase viscosity. Common examples include:Carbomer, acrylate (ester) copolymer, C10-30 alkyl acrylate crosslinked polymer, hydroxyethyl cellulose.

• Oil-Based Thickeners: These thickeners are typically used in oil-based products to provide the desired texture. They are often found in products like lipsticks and lip balms. Common examples include:Dextrin palmitate, pure beeswax, etc.

Considerations for Thickeners in Formulation

When selecting thickeners for a skincare formula, factors such as pH value, stability, transparency, rheological properties, appearance, color, electrolyte stability, and regulatory requirements should be considered.

Need for Neutralization: Some thickeners (such as Carbomer) are acidic polyelectrolytes that require neutralization with alkali to achieve optimal thickening performance. Neutralization causes the molecular chains to extend, increasing viscosity.

Appearance Transparency: This refers to the transparency of the system after thickening. For products that require transparency (such as transparent gels, toners), thickeners with good transparency should be selected.

Rheology: This includes viscosity, elasticity, and thixotropy, which describe how the system flows and deforms under external forces. Different product forms require different rheological properties, which affect the formulation and skin feel.

Salt Tolerance: This refers to the stability and thickening effect of thickeners in electrolyte-containing (salty) systems. This is important for complex formulations containing electrolytes.

Viscosity: This measures the resistance of a fluid to flow, reflecting the thickening effect. Different cosmetics have different viscosity requirements.

Yield Stress: This is the minimum force required to suspend solid particles or insoluble substances in the system. It is crucial for products containing suspended particles.

Shear Resistance: This refers to the ability of a thickener to maintain its performance when subjected to shear forces (such as stirring or application). Good shear resistance helps maintain product stability.

pH Stability: Thickeners have specific pH ranges in which they are effective, and they can affect the overall pH of the product. Different skin types have different suitable pH ranges, so the product's pH must be appropriate.

Temperature Stability: The performance of thickeners may change at different temperatures, including thickening effects and stability. Some products need to remain stable at varying temperatures.

Emulsifying Ability: Some thickeners have emulsifying properties that help form stable emulsions. This is crucial for products like emulsions and creams.

Applicable Systems: Different thickeners are suited to different cosmetic systems, such as water-based formulations, emulsions, creams, gels, etc. The choice should be based on the product type.

Compatibility: The solubility of thickeners in various solvents and their interaction with other ingredients should be considered, as these interactions can affect the overall performance of the formulation.

ShengQing‘s Thickning Agent List：click to link